Return to CVD homepage
Search the CVD website Make a tax-deductible contribution to CVD We welcome your feedback
Return to CVD homepage
What's new?
Online library
Order materials
Get involved!
Links related to electoral reform
About CVD

2003 Pennsylvania Judicial Elections

November 2003

Judicial elections provide insight into the distribution of votes across the state and the level of competitiveness in regions of the state.  The follow charts and links show the distribution of votes for Supreme Court and Superior Court by US congressional district.  All data are unofficial results from the state of Pennsylvania.

We have tallied the percentage received by each candidate in each congressional district and summarize the data  in the following tables.

Max Baer was elected to the Supreme Court with over 50% of the vote, even though he had the most votes in fewer than one-third of the congressional districts in the state.  The same distribution of districts allow a party that wins a majority of the house vote in the Pennsylvania to win less than one-third of the seats in the delegation.

Supreme Court

Candidate Votes Percent of Vote Percent of Districts Districts Won
Max Baer (D) 1,273,278 51.7% 31.6% 6 of 19
Joan Orie Melvin (R) 1,188,072 48.3% 68.4% 13 of 19

Max Baer won over half of the votes but won fewer than one-third of the districts.  Joan Orie Melvin, in contrast, won less than half the votes but won over two-thirds of the seats.

By Congressional District, Baer won 6 districts (1, 2, 11, 12, 14 and 18), and Melvin won 13.

Superior Court (elect 3)

Candidates Panella, McCaffery and Gantman were elected to the Superior Court.

Breakdown of judicial results by congressional district

Candidate Votes Districts 
in First
District 
in Top 3
Panella (D) 1,132,135 2 9
McCaffery (D) 1,130,204 4 8
Gantman (R) 1,121,082  10* 14
Driscoll (D) 1,114,962 2 7
Bowman (R) 1,013,501 0* 11
Dolbin (R)  975,500 1 8

* Two districts (16 and 19) are too close to call between Gantman (R) and Bowman (R) for first place. (With unofficial totals completed, Gantman leads Bowman in each district by just over 100 votes.)


Return to top of page


______________________________________________________________________
Copyright ¬© 2003     The Center for Voting and Democracy
6930 Carroll Ave, Suite 610, Takoma Park, MD 20912
(301) 270-4616        info@fairvote.org