Seats to Votes Distortion

Seats-to Votes Distortion: measures the extent to which one party wins a greater percentage of seats than votes and the other party wins a smaller percentage of seats than votes.  You add the percentage distortion for each party and divide by two.  For example, if Democrats won 10% more seats than votes and Republicans 6% fewer seats than votes, the distortion would be 8.0%.

Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25      
 State 
Tennessee
Michigan
New Jersey
North Carolina
Pennsylvania
Connecticut
Louisiana
Colorado
New York
Maryland
Missouri
Indiana
Illinois
Ohio
Florida
California
Minnesota
Texas
Wisconsin
Virginia
Washington   
Mississippi
Utah
Alabama
South Carolina
Score
1.17%
1.45%
2.48%
2.56%
2.96%
3.97%
4.70%
4.90%
5.07%
5.31%
5.56%
5.66%
6.22%
6.41%
6.48%
6.94%
7.41%
7.78%
7.87%
8.52%
8.59%
8.62%
8.64%
8.80%
8.93%
           Rank
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50      
 State 
Nevada
Kansas
Georgia
Vermont
West Virginia
Massachusetts  
Oklahoma
New Mexico
Iowa
Arizona
Alaska
Oregon
Kentucky
South Dakota
Nebraska
Arkansas
Rhode Island
Idaho
Wyoming
Delaware
Maine
Hawaii
New Hampshire
North Dakota
Montana
Score
9.06%
9.19%
10.72%
11.80%
12.16%
15.40%
16.56%
18.92%
22.75%
23.21%
22.49%
23.63%
24.16%
25.73%
27.24%
29.20%
29.45%
30.69%
30.87%
31.59%
32.83%
33.77%
44.21%
45.81%
47.39%
Ranking the States
Please see menu on the left for the various rankings.

States are ranked in the following categories:

Voter Turnout: The percentage of the voting eligible population which voted in a state's U.S. House elections (as opposed to statewide and presidential elections). We use population estimates by Professor Michael McDonald at George Mason University.  His figures estimate the number of voting age adults who are eligible to vote, which means they excludes non-citizens and ex-felons in states that disenfranchise them.

Representation: This index measures the percentage of adult voters in a state who voted for the winning candidate in House elections; it is determined by multiplying voter turnout in U.S. House races by the percentage of votes cast for winning candidates.

Landslide Index: Percentage of all races won by at least 20%

Margin of Victory: The winner's percentage of all votes cast minus the second-place candidate's percentage

Seats-to-Votes Distortion: The seats-to votes distortion measures the extent to which one party wins a greater percentage of seats than votes and the other party wins a smaller percentage of seats than votes.  You add the percentage distortion for each party and divide by two.  For example, if Democrats won 10% more seats than votes and Republicans 6% fewer seats than votes, the distortion would be 8.0%.

Democracy Index: A state's average ranking in key categories: average margin of victory (measuring overall competitiveness), landslide index(measuring number of somewhat competitive races), seats-to-votes distortion(measuring how well the intent of voters was reflected by results) and representation index (weighted double, as it measures both voter participation and the percentage of effective votes that elect someone)