Why is the victory threshold eight votes?
The victory threshold in choice voting derives from a straightforward formula that identifies the fewest number of votes that only the winning number of candidates can obtain. In percentage terms, the victory threshold equals:

______________ %        + 1 vote
(seats elected) + 1

For instance, if electing ONE candidate (like a mayor), here's how the formula determines the victory threshold

100                                100
______ %  + 1 vote   =  ____  + 1 =     50% + 1
(1 + 1)                   2

This of course is obviously true. A candidate is sure win once he or she receives an absolute majority of 50% plus one of the votes.  Two candidates could each win 50%, but only one can win 50% plus one.

If electing NINE seats, here's how we determine the victory threshold.

100                                100
______ %  + 1 vote   =  ____ + 1 =      10% + 1
(9 + 1)                   10

Consider that if nine candidates win 10% plus one, that collectively is 90% plus nine. While 10 candidates could earn 10% of the vote, only nine can win 10% plus one vote.

In the video, we are electing THREE seats, the victory threshold is 25% plus one.

100                                100
______ %  + 1 vote   =  ____ + 1 =      25% + 1
(3 + 1)                   4

In our video, there are 31 voters.  25% of 31 is a fraction more than 7 votes. The next highest whole number is 8 votes. That's our victory threshold. To see why this makes sense, consider our example. If three candidate win 8 votes, they collectively have 24 votes. The most votes that any other candidate could have is 7. Eight  votes is the minimum number of votes that only three candidates can win.

A point about majority rule: Note how this victory threshold ensures majority rule. If 51% of voters all support two or more candidates as their top choices in an election for three seats, they will be sure of winning two of three seats. If 51% of voters all support five or more candidates as their top choices in an election for nine seats, they will be sure of winning five of nine seats.  
Recent Articles
October 19th 2009
A better election system
Lowell Sun

Election expert Doug Amy explains how choice voting can "inject new blood" into the elections of Lowell (MA), and give voters a greater incentive to participate.

October 16th 2009
Haven't Detroit voters spoken enough?
Livingston Daily

In Detroit, there have been three mayors in the past two years and the current one has come under scrutiny. Perhaps a system like instant runoff voting will help bring political stability to motor city.

August 21st 2009
Black candidate for Euclid school board to test new voting system
Cleveland Plain Dealer

Limited voting, a form of proportional voting, will be used in Euclid (OH), in the hopes of allowing better representation of minorities.

July 2nd 2009
Reforming Albany
New York Times

FairVote's Rob Richie responds in a letter to the editor making the case for proportional voting systems to bring substantive reform to New York's legislature.