Full
Representation Around the World: Articles Arranged by Country
Note: For more articles, try a Google News search on
"proportional representation"
Afghanistan Try
these links for background information on Afghan politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Afghanistan, Wikipedia.org: Afghanistan
IPS News: "Insecurity Threatens
Newly-Won Women's Rights." The new constitution for
Afghanistan includes full representation provisions as well as
quotas for women representatives in the national legislature.
January 14, 2004.
Armenia Try
these links for background information on Armenian politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Armenia, Wikipedia.org: Armenia, Psephos: Armenia.
Eurasianet.org: ���Coalition Government Likely Outcome of May 25
Parliament Elections in Armenia.��� Article written a few
days before the 2003 elections for parliament and for a referendum
on adopting a new constitution, discussing the parties and the
issues at stake. In 2002, Austria adopted a parallel system for its
legislature, which is a combination of full represention and
winner-take-all. May 22, 2003.
Australia Try these links for background information on
Australian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Australia, Wikipedia.org: Australia
Crickey.com: "How Tough is the QLD Question?" Senator
John Cherry analyzes the Queensland electoral statistics, and ABC
election analyst Antony Green provides a response. January 20,
2004.
Sydney Morning Herald: ���Ideas to save our withering democracy.���
Candidate for presidency of the Australian Labor Party presents a
manifesto stating her beliefs about Australian politics and
democracy. She believes that full representation leads to higher
turnout and fewer wasted votes. August 7, 2003.
PM, Australia: ���Howard���s Senate plans .��� The Australian
Prime Minister has suggested a measure that would reduce the powers
of the Senate. August 11, 2003.
The Guardian: ���One Nation leader in fraud case.��� Brief
article about the defeat of ex-Australian Member of Parliament
Pauline Hanson, and her disintegrating One Nation party. July 16,
2003.
The Age: ���Sword alleges ALP branch-stacking.���
Australian Labor Party leader Greg Sword comes down on the practice
of ���branch-stacking��� (insincerely stuffing local party branches with
members in order to gain control of them). The Australian Workers
Unions has made a proposal for full representation (proportional
representation) to be used for candidate selection within the Labor
party. March 5, 2003.
Sydney Morning Herald, Australia: ���Major changes in the house as the mice all
roar.��� In the New South Wales region of Australia, which
includes Sydney, small parties are gaining ground on the biggest
three parties (Labor, Liberal, and National.) The Parliament of New
South Wales is divided into two houses, the Legislative Assembly, or
lower house, and the legislative council, or upper house. Elections
to the lower house are divided into 93 single member districts,
using instant runoff voting, and the upper house is elected by
choice voting in one state-wide district. March 1, 2003.
Austria Try
these links for background information on Austrian politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Austria, Wikipedia.org: Politics of Austria, Electionresources.org: Austria, IFES
Electionguide for elections in 2002.
Reuters: ���Austrians Begin Voting, Outcome Wide Open.���
Article written on the day of the 2002 elections forcecasts big
losses for the Freedom Party of Austria, which turned out to be
accurate. November 24, 2002.
Azerbaijan Try
these links for backgroud information on Azerbaijan politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Azerbaijan, Wikipedia.org: Politics of Azerbaijan
Eurasianet.org: ���Little to Lose: Opposition in Azerbaijan .���
This article discusses the political effects of a referendum passed
in 2002, which eliminates full representation from Azerbaijan
national government, and thus decreases the ability of dissenting
parties to participate in government. It also provides extensive
background on the history of political parties in Azerbaijan since
independence. February 3, 2003.
Bahamas Try these
links for background information on politics and elections in the
Bahamas: Electionworld.org: Bahamas, Wikipedia: Bahamas
Nassau Guardian: ���Constitution Reform booklet launched .���
Constitutional reform is underway in the Bahamas, where the
Constitutional Reform Commission has begun its public education
campaign. The Commission intends to use public referendums to guide
the process. One of the issues up for discussion is wither the
Bahamas should move to a full representation system. July 16,
2003.
Bangladesh Try these links for background information on
politics and elections in Bangladesh: Electionworld.org: Bangladesh, Wikipedia: Bangladesh
The Daily Star: "All-party
consensus needed to increase parliament seats." Leading
intellectuals and professionals critique the government's decision
to increase the number of constituencies used in parliamentary
elections. January 17, 2004.
The New Nation: "Badruddoza says:
'I resigned to avert constitutional crisis'." Following
his resignation former President Badruddoza Chowdhury reiterated a
call for political reforms, including proportional representation.
January 6, 2004.
The Daily Star, Bangladesh: ���Parliamentary reforms: Laws for lawmakers are the
crying need.��� Opinion article suggests that Bangladesh���s
Parliament suffers from corruption and self-interest. Advocates
various structural reforms, including the use of a full
representation system to replace the current plurality system. July
22, 2003.
Barbados Try
these links for background information on Barbados politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Barbados, Wikipedia.org: Politics of Barbados, Electionresources.org: Barbados
Barbados Daily Nation : ���Reasonings: Democracy under threat ?���
Editorial in favor of full representation in Barbados. Under the
current plurality system, there are only two opposition members in
the 28 member parliament. January 20, 2003.
Botswana Try these links for background information on
Botswana politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Botswana, Wikipedia: Botswana, Psephos: Botswana
Mmegi, Bostwana: "Koma calls for
proportional representation." Botswana member of
parliament renews his call for proportional representation, arguing
that the nation would receive international praise for using such a
system. November 26, 2003.
Daily News, Botswana: ���Perpetual rule, opposition party splits frustrating,
says MISA director.��� The director of the Media Institute
for Southern Africa, speaking at a Botswana Congress Party
conference, calls for a an electoral system combining full
representation (proportional representation) with single-member
districts. Botswana currently uses the plurality system, and the
National Assembly has been dominated by a single party for decades.
July 28, 2003.
Mmegi, Botswana: ���BCP revels in progress.��� The Botswana
Congress Party is calling for a change from the plurality system, to
a combined system of full representation. The BCP won 11.3% of the
vote in the 1999 National Assembly elections, but only won 2.5% of
the seats. July 25, 2003.
Republic of Botswana, Botswana: ���Koosaletse criticises govt pact with US.���
The Botswana Congress Party, who support full representation, are
critical of a deal that the ruling party has made, which exempts US
nationals from provisions of the International Criminal Court. July
24, 2003.
Bulgaria Try these links for background information on
Bulgarian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Bulgaria, Wikipedia: Bulgaria
Novinte.com: ���Bulgaria���s Electoral Code Passed at First
Reading .��� Bulgaria���s Parliament passed a new Electoral
code which changes the voting system from direct party list full
representation to a parallel semi-proportional system. July 2,
2003
Cambodia Try these
links for background information on Cambodian politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Cambodia, Wikipedia: Cambodia
Voice of America News: ���Ruling Party Wins Cambodian Election .���
Article discusses the results of the election and their
implications. August, 2003.
Associated Press Asia: ���Officials Confirm Hun Sen Party���s Leads.���
Cambodia, which uses a party list form of full representation, also
has a requirement that parties or coalitions must have two-thirds
control in Parliament to form a government. The KPK or Cambodian
People���s Party, led by Hun Sen, has won a clear majority of the
seats, but nevertheless must form a coalition in order to create a
government. The difficulty of this may lead to prolonged political
deadlock. July 31, 2003.
Canada FairVote Canada is the leading group
working toward electoral reform in the country. Try these links for background information on Canadian
politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Canada, Wikipedia: Canada. Also see
information on British Columbia's Citizens' Assembly on Electoral
Reform and electoral reform projects around the
nation.
Rabble News: "Jack Layton: bringing energy and new hope."
Canada will be holding a national election this spring, and the
Liberals are suddenly beset by a scandal that could weaken their
stranglehold on parliament. The New Democratic Party is rising
in the polls, and its leader has said that if it's in a position to
allow the Liberals to run the government, a non-negotiable demand is
a national referendum on PR. February 17, 2004.
The Miami Herald: "Canadian Briefs - Nova
Scotia Premier supports electing senators for vacant
positions." Whereas Canadian senators are traditionally
appointed by the Prime Minister, the Nova Scotia Premier will follow
Alberta's lead and hold elections for seats as they become vacant.
NDP leader Jack Layton dismissed this move and asserted that steps
towards electoral reform should lead to full representation in the
House of Commons. February 8, 2004.
The Globe and Mail: "Panel to recommend
proportional voting." The independent Law Commission of
Canada will recommend in a March report that the House of Commons
adopt a full representation system for electing members of
parliament. Critics fear that such a change would result in
governmental chaos, while advocates hope that it would solve some of
the problems facing the nation, such as low voter turnout and civic
participation. February 2, 2004. In "Is Canada the mature
nation the PM says it is?", the same author, John
Ibbitson, then raises questions as to how politics would play out
among the major parties with a full representation system in place.
February 2, 2004
The Globe and Mail: "PR would have saved the
PCs." This commentary advocates full representation in
Canada as a way to increase the representation of minority parties
and get more people out to vote. January 2, 2004.
Toronto Star: "Ministers may face $500 fines: Liberals explore new
voting methods -- State your choice by phone or
Internet?" Liberal party to create a Democratic Renewal
Secretariat to explore fixed election dates and alternative voting
methods, including proportional representation. December 9,
2003.
Toronto Star: "McGuinty likes
citizens assembly initiative, B.C. premier says." Praise
for the British Columbian Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform,
which is looking into changing the province's electoral system.
November 24, 2003.
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation:
���Liberals want to change the way Quebec
votes.��� The Liberal Party, which has majority control in
Quebec���s provincial government, have announced that it plans to
introduce some form of full representation in time for the next
election. The latest election was on April 14, 2003, and the next
election doesn���t have a definitive date, as election terms are not
fixed in Canada. July 11, 2003.
Elm Street Magazine: ���The Unjust Society.��� A women���s group in
Canada discusses full representation (proportional representation)
as a means to allow more equal representation for women in
Parliament, and discuss the state of the women���s movement in
general. July 3, 2003.
CBC News Online: ���Is proportional representation really on the
agenda?��� Article discusses various possible motivations
for Quebec government to move towards full representation. Multiple
parties are interested, although not committed, and it is not clear
how strong of a full representation system will be put in place if
there is a change. April 1, 2003.
Hailfax Daily News : ���Handicapping the Tories.��� Profiles of
candidates vying for leadership of the Canadian Progressive
Conservative party. David Orchard, a long-shot candidate, supports
full representation. February 7, 2003.
Leader-Post: ���Nystrom and Proctor get nod for critic
posts.��� Full representation is a top priority of the
newly appointed justice critic for the New Democratic Party of
Canada, Lorne Nystrom. February 5, 2003.
CBC News Online : ���Layton vows to put debate back in Canadian
politics.��� Jack Layton, the recently elected leader of
the Canadian federal New Democratic Party, calls for a national
referendum on full representation. January 26, 2003.
CBC New Brunswick : ���Prof lobbies for electoral change .���
Article discusses the support of political scientists for full
representation in Canada. January 23, 2003
Fair Vote Canada: ���Political scientists from 34 Canadian universities
call for national referendum on electoral reform.��� 103
political scientists from 34 universities have endorsed a call for a
public consultation and public referendum process that would enable
Canada to switch to full representation (proportional representaion). January 22, 2003.
Globe and Mail : ���NDP risks stagnating, Nystrom warns .���
Lorne Nystrom, a candidate for the Canadian New Democratic Party,
criticizes his opponents. All candidates, however, are in favor of
full representation.
The Vancouver Sun: ���NDP front-runner promises referendum.��� Jack
Layton, the frontrunner for New Democratic Party leadership in
Canada, promises to make a referedum on full representation a
condition of joining into a coalition government. Includes a table
illustrating how the distribution of seats in Parliament would have
been different with full representation. January 6, 2003.
China
(Hong Kong) Try these links for background information
on Hong Kong politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Hong Kong, Psephos: Hong Kong
The Straits Times: "Pro-democracy vs pro-China
in Legco polls." Elections for the Hong Kong Legislative
Council (Legco) will occur this year, using a full representation
system where voters choose their preferred party. According to this
article, the elections are already heating up, as certain political
parties are being criticized for their support of the Beijing
government. January 22, 2004.
Estonia Try these links for background
information on Estonian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Estonia, Wikipedia: Estonia
VOA News: ���Estonia Holds Parliamentary Elections .���
Article written on the day of the March elections to Estonia���s
Parliament. The result was that a coalition government was formed
between Res Publica, Reform, and Rahvaliit. March 2, 2003.
Fiji Try
these links for background information on Fijian politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Fiji, Wikipedia: Fiji
Reuters: ���Fijian verdict welcomed.��� The Supreme Court
of the Fiji Islands ruled that the Prime Minister must give
proportional representation in his Cabinet to all parties with more
than 10 seats in the House of Representatives. This means that the
main opposition party, the Fiji Labour Party, will gain seats in the
cabinet. The Fiji Labour party has 27 of the 71 seats in the House,
the Soqosoqo Duavata ni Lewenivanua (SDL) / United Fiji Party has
32, the Matanitu Vanua (MV) / Conservative Alliance Party has 6, and
the rest of the seats are held by smaller parties. At present the
government is formed by a coalition of SDL and MV. July 19,
2003.
France (Corsica)
Try this links for background information on Corsican politics
and elections: Widipedia: Corsica
The Guardian : ���Corsicans say No to home rule .��� A plan for
giving Corsica greater political autonomy from France was submitted
to the Corsican people by referendum. It was narrowly defeated, by
51% to 49%. The plan would have created a single Corsican assembly
elected by full representation. July 7, 2003.
Ghana Try
these links for background information on politics and elections in
Ghana: Electionworld.org: Ghana, Wikipedia: Ghana
GhanaWeb: "Go to the Court for redress - Papa
Owusu-Ankomah." Speaking on the general theme of
'National Integration," Professor John Kaburise of the University
for Development Studies advocates proportional representation in
Ghana. November 21, 2003.
Ghanaian Chronicle, Ghana: ���MP pushes for proportional representation.���
A Member of Parliament in Ghana suggested that the Parliament should
change to a full representation (proportional representation)
system, from the current plurality system. Also, different formulas
are discussed for adding seats to the Parliament to cope with
Ghana���s growing population. February 27, 2003.
Greece Try
these links for background information on Greek politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Greece, Wikipedia: Greece
Kathimerini: ���An old favorite. ��� Editorial suggests
political motivations behind the Greek PASOK party���s attention to
possible changes in the electoral law. The PASOK party controls a
majority of the seats in the Greek Parliament. July 28, 2003.
Kathimerini: ���With what political compass... ��� Discussion
of the political factors involved in a likely change in the Greek
electoral system. July 21, 2003.
ERT, Athens: ���Simitis aims for electoral reform .��� In
Greece, the socialist PASOK party has put forward plans for
electoral reform. They have majority control in Parliament, with 158
of 300 seats. The main opposition is the conservative New Democracy
party, with 125 seats. The Communist KKE party have 11 seats, the
socialist Coalition of the Left and Progress has 6 seats, and the
socialist DIKKI party has no seats at present. July 19, 2003.
Kathimerini: ���A clash before elections.��� Debates between
parties over possible changes to the electoral law, including a
change in Greek���s system of full representation. To make the article
more clear, the socialist PASOK party has majority control in
Parliament, with 158 of 300 seats. The main opposition is the
conservative New Democracy party, with 125 seats. The Communist KKE
party have 11 seats, the socialist Coalition of the Left and
Progress has 6 seats, and the socialist DIKKI party has no seats at
present. July 15, 2003.
India Try these links for
background information on Indian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: India, Wikipedia: India
The Hindu: ���Jaitly: Religious quotas dangerous.��� The
ruling party in India has rejected a bill which would introduce full
representation (proportional representation), as well as reserve
seats in Parliament for certain minority groups. July 25, 2003.
People���s Democracy: ���Women Demand Quota, Police Arrest Them .���
For years, the Indian government has been delaying action on a bill
to reserve seats for women in parliament and state assemblies. June
22, 2003.
Oherlad: ���Defections And Proportional
Representation.��� Editorial argues that India should
change their election system from plurality to full representation.
The author believes that full representation will lead to more
issues-based campaigns, less nepotism, less distortion of seats per
votes, and greater minority representation. May 28, 2003
Indonesia Try these links for
background information on Indonesian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Indonesia, Wikipedia.org: Indonesia, Psephos: Indonesia
The Jakarta Post: "A guide to the 2004
elections." Indonesia will go through two national
elections this year, including its first direct presidential vote
ever. Due to criticism of corruption and a lack of responsiveness in
the government, electoral reform has been taking place, particularly
in the presidential election system. Legislatures will continue to
be elected using full representation, but some districts will be
broken up in order to have representatives that more closely reflect
their constituents. January 26, 2004.
Ireland Try these links for
background information on Irish politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Ireland, Wikipedia: Ireland
Politics.ie: "Constituency Boundary
revisions favour large parties - Greens." The Green Party
has asserted that the proposed move to smaller constituencies will
make it more difficult for small parties and independents to win
seats in the Parliament. January 8, 2004.
Irish Examiner: ���Let���s have one constituency for European
polls.��� Because new countries are being added to the
European Parliament, the share of seats for countries already
represented in the Parliament, such as Ireland, is decreasing, and
therefore constituent boundaries will have to be redrawn. The author
of this piece suggests that instead of drawing a new set of
boundaries, Ireland should elect EP members as a single national
constituency, using full representation, of course. July 18,
2003.
U.TV: ���Sinn Fein in plea over Senate elections .���
The Sinn Fein party is advocating that the Irish Senate (the Seanad)
be directly elected by universal suffrage. July 15, 2003.
Economic and Social Research Council:
���Devolution remains popular despite problems with Good
Friday Agreement.��� The Economic and Social Research
Council organized a conference on devolution in Northern Ireland.
Research was presented showing that many people in Ireland support
devolution over other options. Another paper was presented, arguing
that a mixed member proportional system based on instant runoff
voting might be preferable to choice voting. March 4, 2003.
Israel Try these links for background information on Israeli
politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Israel, Wikipedia.org: Israel
Ha���aretz: ���Was return to single ballot a mistake?���
Israel has changed from a twin ballot system to a single ballot
system. In the twin ballot system, voters placed one vote for the
Prime Minister, and a separate vote for a party list. The single
ballot system discards the direct vote for the Prime Minister, but
maintains the party list vote, which is the full representation
component of the election. January 29, 2003.
TIME: ���Israel Votes, But Little Will Change .��� The
author criticizes Israel���s party list system of full representation,
and discusses the balance of power in the Knesset, which he views as
leading to a stagnant continuance of current deadlock. January 27,
2003.
Israel Insider : ���An Israeli democrat���s lament .��� Editorial
attacking the Israeli government and its system of full
representation. January 27, 2003
Italy Try these links for background information on
Italian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Italy, Wikipedia: Italy
Agenzia Giornalistica Italia: "Reforms: Mazzella
proposing new format for ruling parties." Italy's
Minister of Public Administration suggests electoral reform, to
include full representation in the parliament. February 7, 2004.
Agenzia Giornalistica Italia: ���Reform: Follini, we agree with premiership
.��� Comments from Italian Christian Democratic Union secretary Marco
Follini on the possibility of further electoral system reform. July
7, 2003.
Japan Try these links for background information on
Italian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Japan, Psephos: Japan, Wikipedia: Japan
The Japan Times: "A place for 'judicial
positivism'." This editorial analyzes the recent Supreme
Court ruling in favor of the current electoral system. January 20,
2004.
Asahi Shimbun: "Balance vote
disparity." This editorial criticizes a recent ruling of
the Supreme Court to uphold the current electoral process, arguing
that there need to be reform in order to minimize "vote-weight gaps"
and improve the system. January 16, 2004.
The Japan Times: "Upper House electoral
system upheld." Japan's Supreme Court ruled that the full
representation system used to elect members of the Upper House is
consistent with their constitution. January 15, 2004. For
more information on this case, see the Asahi Shimbun article "Weighty Issue: Top court
upholds election." January 15, 2004.
The Japan Times: "Reliance on Komeito
reflects LDP decline." Recent elections reveal the
workings of coalitions among the ruling Liberal Democratic Party
(LDP) and New Komeito and Soka Gakkai -- both third parties. In the
November House of Representatives elections, New Komeito endorsed
LDP candidates running in single-seat districts in exchange for LDP
support of New Komeito members in proportional representation
elections. January 3, 2004.
Daily Yomiuri: "New Komeito tactics
alarm LDP." Article discusses tactics used by political
parties in Japan's proportional representation electoral system.
December 10, 2003.
The Asahi Shimbun: ���Lost decade of politics .��� Editorial
discusses the state of politics in Japan. August 9, 2003.
Kenya Try these links for background information on Kenyan politics
and elections: Electionworld.org: Kenya, Wikipedia: Kenya
Daily Nation: "The past returns to haunt delegates." The
Constitutional Conference in Kenya sparks debate over the country's
electoral system. One participant, Gibson Kamau Kuria, laments the
lack of full representation. January 23, 2004.
The East African Standard: ���The Disabled Must Be Visible By Law.���
Editorial advocating more specific standards for people with
disabilities to be represented in the Kenyan Parliament. February 2,
2003.
The East African Standard: ���Distribution of parliamentary seats is
unfair .��� Editorial pointing out the severe disparities
of representation in Kenya, such that electoral districts with very
different population sizes are represented by the same number of
seats in parliament. December 25, 2002.
The East African Standard (Nairobi):
���Law Could Ease Land Rows.��� The author makes
the case for the proposed draft Constitution in Kenya, which
includes regional devolution of powers within a unitary state,
bicameralism, and a mixed member system of full representation. He
explains why this is needed to help resolve tension between
different minority and majority groups within Kenya. November 23,
2002.
Korea
(South) Try this link for background information
on South Korean politics and elections: Electionworld.org: South Korea
Korea Herald: "Odd path to
equality." Korea's National Assembly's Special Political
Reform Committee has proposed establishing 26 additional
constituencies where only women will run for legislative seats.
February 17, 2004.
Korea Herald: "Panel passes election
revision bills, but far from reaching compromise on other
changes." A political reform committee has come to a
consensus on three electoral changes, including a reduction in the
number of parliamentary seats elected using full representation and
requiring half of these positions to be occupied by women. February
10, 2004.
The Dong-A Ilbo: "New Trend for General
Election - Women Rule Over." This article describes the
current scramble by political parties to find women
candidates. The situation arose after all parties committed
themselves to allocating half of their full representation seats in
the legislature to women. January 27, 2004.
Korea Times: "Electoral Reform Panel Back in
Action." After some delay, the Special Committee
for Political Reform is set to reconvene in the hopes that lawmakers
can come to an agreement on a long-awaited electoral reform bill.
January 11, 2004.
Korea Times: "Hopes for Electoral
Reforms Dashed." Political parties are unlikely to come
to an agreement on electoral reform this legislative cycle. December
29, 2003.
Korea Herald: "Reform panel to finalize
plans today." A special committee on political reform in
the National Assembly will discuss and vote on a plan to change the
electoral system. Full representaion is being considered and is
a particularly contentious issue. December 22, 2003.
Korea Herald: "Roh sends Assembly
political reform plan." President Roh's plan for
electoral reform supports full representation. December 18,
2003.
JoongAng Daily: "Roh presents reform
plan ." President Roh Moo-hyun is proposing electoral
reform in South Korea, to include full representation. December
18, 2003.
Korea Times: "FTC Alerts Chaebol Again
Over Corporate Governance System." A proposed plan for
market reform calls for using cumulative voting in corporations to
strengthen the voice of small shareholders. October 19, 2003.
Korea Herald: ���A gender-equal society.��� Editorial in favor
of political and economic reforms to help South Korean women,
including raising the required ratio of female candidates for the
legislature. July 7, 2003.
Lebanon Try
these links for background information on Lebanese politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Lebanon, Wikipedia: Lebanon
Daily Star, Lebanon: ���Iraq���s governing council: foul or fair?"
The author, a former Jordanian ambassador, believes that the Iraqi
governing council should be based on full representation rather than
a rigidly divisive system based on ethnic and religious groupings.
August 8, 2003.
Monday Morning, Lebanon: ���Lebanon still in thrall to the sectarian
mindset.��� Interview with a member of the Lebanese
Parliament. He critiques the government as being sectarian and
elitist, and names full representation as a possible solution. July
22, 2003.
Daily Star, Lebanon: ���Karami says ���small election district���
best.��� A proposal has been made to elect Parliamentary
seats in Lebanon using full representation. In this article, a
Lebanese Member of Parliament registers his opinion against full
representation. Currently, Lebanon uses a form of at-large plurality
voting known as party block, where a party winning a plurality of
the votes in a multiple member district receives all the seats in
that district.
Lethoso
AllAfrica.com: "Lethoso: Focus on
Challenges to Multiparty Democracy." Although democracy
remains fragile in Lethoso according to a South African think tank,
recent electoral reforms, including moving from a winner-take-all to
full representation system, have reduced the probability of
election-time unrest. January 15, 2004.
Liberia Try
these links for background information on Liberian politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Liberia, Wikipedia: Liberia
Inter Press Service : ���Taylor Seeks Re-Election, Despite Growing
Opposition .��� Article that discusses the struggle for
peace and democracy in war-torn Liberia. January 30, 2003
Malta Try these links for
background information on Maltese politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Malta, Wikipedia: Malta
Di-ve News: ���Pro-EU alliance emerging.��� Article
discusses the possible formation of an alliance between parties in
Malta who are generally at odds with each other, for the purpose of
a campaign to enter the European Union. January 8, 2003.
Mexico Try these links for background information on
Mexican politics and elections: Instituto Federal
Electoral, Electionworld.org: Mexico, Wikipedia: Mexico
Elections to Mexico's Congress: A brief
description of the voting systems used to elect Mexico's two houses
of Congress. See also Results of Chamber of Deputies Election
2003, a table which analyzes the results in terms of
votes and seats won by each party.
Republic Mexico City Bureau: ���Mexico's voters deal Fox setback, deny him a majority
in Congress.��� Mexican President Vicente Fox is a member
of the National Action Party (PAN), which suffered losses in the
Chamber of Deputies election, weakening his position. The strongest
party in Congress is the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI),
the party which controlled Mexico from the time of the revolution in
1910-1917 until the elections in 2000 where Fox became President.
July 7, 2003.
Associated Press: ���Campaigning north of the border.��� Six of
the candidates running for Mexico���s lower house of Congress are U.S.
residents, although they are Mexican citizens. Such candidates are
spending time campaigning for support in the U.S., pledging to gain
a voice in Congress for Mexican citizens living in America. Although
millions of U.S. residents are technically eligible to vote in
Mexican elections, they are not allowed an absentee ballot, and so
must travel to Mexico to vote. Mexico uses a mixed member system of
full representation. June 18, 2003.
Monaco Try these links for background information on
politics and elections in Monaco: Electionworld.org: Monaco, Wikipedia: Monaco
Associated Press : ���Monaco Votes For Parliamentary Seats .���
Article written on the day of the 2003 elections, in which the
opposition party won 21 of 24 seats from what had been the ruling
party for decades. February 9, 2003.
Namibia Try these links for background information on
Namibian politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Namibia, Wikipedia: Namibia
The Namibian: ���Debate starting on amendments to Electoral
Act.��� Although the ward system of single member districts
has been abolished in favor of full representation through the Local
Authorities Amendment Act, single member districts still remain a
part of the Electoral Act. An amendment is proposed to remove them
from the text of the electoral act as well. June 19, 2003.
The Namibian: ���SWAPO Members ���Want Ward System.������ Article
discusses the results of a survey by the Institute for Public Policy
Research. SWAPO stats for ���South West African People���s
Organization,��� and it is the strongest political party in Namibia by
far. Although SWAPO officials chose a full representation system for
local government in Namibia, the survey found that most supporters
of the SWAPO party would have prepared a single member district
system. February 27, 2003.
Nepal Try these links for background information on
Nepalese politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Nepal, Wikipedia: Nepal
The Guardian: ���Maoist emerges to claim
Nepal.��� Article about the Nepalese rebels, who are asking
for multi-party democracy and full representation (proportional
representation). May 29, 2003.
People���s Review, Nepal: ���Dr. Johan Galtung suggests for revision of
constitution.��� A peace studies professor suggests full
representation as part of a peace plan for Nepal, which has been
engaged in a civil war since 1996. May 22-28, 2003.
New Zealand The
Electoral Reform
Coalition advocates full representation in New
Zealand. Also, try these
links for background information on politics and elections in New
Zealand: Electionworld.org: New Zealand, Wikipedia: New Zealand
New Zealand Herald: "Time to take
confusion out of voting." This editorial supports the
desire of retiring Electoral Commission chief to have a single,
independent agency responsible for all electoral issues. January 16,
2004.
Scoop: "Government confirms changes to DHB
elections." New Zealand Citizens will now be able to
elect all members of their District Health Board using single
transferable voting. December 17, 2003.
The National Business Review, New Zealand: "Poll: Electors yet to
be won over by the merits of MMP." A poll taken over
seven years indicates that New Zealand citizens are evenly split
when it comes to favoring the former first-past-the-post system or
their own mixed member proportional representation system. December
10, 2003.
Scoop: "MMP electoral system is working well." A
Progressive Party press release applauds the New Zealand mixed
member proportional representation system. December 1, 2003.
Australian Broadcasting Company
Online: ���New Zealand debates whether to scrap exclusive Maori
Parliamentary seats.��� Debate in New Zealand over whether
to abolish the seats in Parliament reserved for Maori members. Some
have suggested that New Zealand���s Mixed Member Proportional system
of full representation should be able to provide fair representation
for the Maori people in itself. May 25, 2003.
Pakistan Try
these links for background information on Pakistani politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: Pakistan, Wikipedia: Pakistan
Daily Times, Pakistan: ���35 in race for 22 seats from NWFP .���
Article provides background on Pakistan���s Senate, which is elected
by the members of the Provincial Assemblies using choice voting. It
also lists the candidates who are running. February 23, 2003.
Hi Pakistan: ���Bargaining for Senate seats in full swing.���
Members of the Pakistan Senate are elected by the members of the
provincial assemblies assemblies (who number 168 in total), using
choice voting. This article discusses the different voting power of
each political party, in terms of how many Senators they will be
able to elect on their own, and how many votes they will have left
over to pool with other parties to elect further Senators. February
16, 2003.
Poland Try these links for background information on
Polish politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Poland, Wikipedia: Poland
Warsaw Business Journal: ���For sale: Euro seats.��� Editorial rails
against the use of proportional representation in Poland, for
elections to the Polish Sejm and the Polish members of the European
Parliament. February 16, 2003.
Russia
Try these links for background information on Russian politics
and elections: Electionworld.org: Russia, Wikipedia: Russia, Ace Project
The Guardian: "Pro Kremlin Party
Sweeps Russia Elections." Discusses the outcome of the
recent Duma elections, in which the United Russia Party consolidated
its power. December 8, 2003. USA today also printed a similar
article.
CNN: "Background: Russian Election Primer."
Describes the Russian electoral system. December 8, 2003.
Radio Free Europe: Russia: ���Centrists Propose Changing Electoral Law.���
Article discusses a proposal by the powerful Unified Russia Party to
raise the minimum threshold of votes that parties would need to gain
seats in the parliament. If passed, such a measure would decrease
the ability of smaller parties to participate in government. October
18, 2002.
Pravda: ���State Duma Speaker Favors 5 Percent Threshold for
Parties in 2003 Parliamentary Elections.��� Brief news
article. Duma speaker is opposed to changing minimum vote threshold
for seats in Russian parliament before the 2003 elections. October
14, 2002.
Serbia Try these links for background information on
South African politics and elections: Electionworld.org: Serbia, Wikipedia: Serbia
B92 News: "G17 Plus inter-party
negotiations continue." As inter-party discussions occur,
Social Democracy party proposes election legislation that would
include full representation. September 9, 2003.
South Africa Try these
links for background information on South African politics and
elections: Electionworld.org: South Africa, Wikipedia: South Africa
News24: ���Electoral system stays as is.��� An electoral
task team has recommended that the 2004 elections take place
according to the current party list system, but most of those on the
team recommend that the system be changed for the 2009
elections. If the system is eventually changed, the new
system, like the current one, will probably incorporate some form of
full representation. March 5, 2003.
Business Day (Johannesburg): ���Marginalised Need Better Access to the Workings of
Parliament.��� Discussing the State of the Nation address,
the author praises South Africa���s system of full representation
(proportional representation), but also feels that the government
should go further in representing and granting access to the people
of South Africa. February 26, 2003.
Business Day (Johannesburg): ���Party List System Needs to Change .���
Editorial supporting a possible change in South Africa from direct
party list full representation to a system of mixed member
proportional representation. January 9, 2003
Sunday Times, South Africa: ���ANC lashes out at IFP/DA on KZN poll.���
Conflict between political parties in the KwaZulu-Natal region of
South Africa. Although the African National Congress party has a
strong majority nationwide, the Inkatha Freedom Party leads the
regional government in KwaZulu-Natal, and they have decided to call
for early elections there, drawing criticism from the ANC.
���Floor-crossing,��� as used in the article, refers to a Member of
Parliament voting differently from the rest of their party.
Sri
Lanka Try these links for background information
on politics and elections in Sri Lanka: Electionworld.org: Sri Lanka, Wikipedia: Sri Lanka
Daily Mirror: "Sri Lanka's Electoral
System: Bogy or asset?" Editorial by Dr. Chandra
Dolawatte defends use of proportional representation in Sri Lanka.
February 14, 2004.
Hindustan Times: "For Chandrika,
ordering snap polls was an agonising decision." This
article analyzes the political situation in Sri Lanka that lead up
to President Kumaratunga's recent dissolving of parliament. February
9, 2004.
Sunday Observer: "Minority parties react
to Electoral Reform Report." An electoral reform
committee interim report advocates a mixed first-past-the-post and
full representation system for Sri Lanka. Muslim leaders welcome the
recommendation, while Tamil (particularly Northeast Tamil) leaders
have some reservations and would like to see full representation as
part of a package aimed at resolving 'the national ethnic problem'.
February 1, 2004.
Daily News: "Select Committee on Electoral Reform recommends: Mixed
PR and first-past-the-post systems." An interim report by
the Committee on Electoral Reforms and endorsed by the major parties
proposes using some full representation in Sri Lanka. January 24,
2004.
Daily Mirror: "President and
Premier reach agreement." The President and Prime
Minister of Sri Lanka recently came to an agreement concerning
electoral reform for the nation. Changes will include full
representation in parliamentary elections, to be used in conjunction
with the first-past-the-post method. January 22, 2004.
Sri Lanka Daily News: "Peace beneficial, says
majority." A recent survey by the Centre for Policy
Alternatives indicates that a majority of Sri Lankans would support
proportional representation based on ethnicity as a way to achieve
peace in the nation. January 7, 2004.
Sri Lanka Daily News: ���PM initiates dialogue with party leaders :
Sub-Committee for Electoral Reforms .��� A parliamentary
committee is formed in Sri Lanka to look at possibilities for
electoral system reform. Sri Lanka currently uses party list full
representation. The committee will deliberate whether to retain the
party list system, to return to plurality, or to introduce a mixed
system. January 30, 2003.
Uganda Try these
links for background information on Ugandan politics and elections:
Electionworld.org: Uganda, Wikipedia: Uganda, Psephos: Uganda
AllAfrica.com: "Must the Winner Always
Take All?" This column describes feelings of
disenfranchisment that lead to low voter turnout as a result of the
winner-take-all system. The author touts full representation as a
way to ensure representation of the multiple parties emerging in
Uganda's political sphere. February 4, 2004.
Ukraine Try these
links for background information on Ukrainian politics and
elections: Wikipedia: Ukraine, Electionworld.org: Ukraine
The Russia Journal: "Ukraine to amend its
Constitution." The Ukrainian parliament passed a bill
that would initiate amendments to the constitution. Highlights of
the bill include moving to indirect election of the president and
adopting full representation in parliamentary elections. December
24, 2003.
UK (England and
general UK) The Electoral Reform Society is the leading
organization working toward electoral reform in the UK. Also try
these links for background information on politics and elections in
the UK: Electionworld.org: United Kingdom, Wikipedia: United Kingdom
epolitix.com: "Hain
backs alternative vote for Commons." Welsh Secretary and
House of Commons Leader Peter Hain vows to support Instant Runoff
Voting for single-member parliamentary districts. February 29, 2004.
Scunthorpe Telegraph: "What the proposals
involve." This article discusses proposed plans for
regional parliaments in the UK and explains what would happen with
and without these models in place. January 20, 2004.
This Is Local London: "Mayoral election vote
system prompts fears of confusion." A new website has
been developed to offer information about London's full
representation system to voters, journalists and electoral officers.
October 15, 2003.
The Guardian: ��� Away with these tribes
.��� An interesting and intelligent editorial
in favor of full representation (proportional representation) in
Britain. The author
argues that retaining the plurality (first-past-the-post) system is
the only thing that will allow a minority-supported,
majority-opposed Conservative government to come to power in the
future. August 1, 2003.<?XML:NAMESPACE PREFIX = O
/>
The Herald : ���English regions can vote to copy Scotland: Assemblies
plan will be decided by referendums .��� Referendums will
be held in three areas of northern England to decide whether to
create new local assemblies to take over powers from the central
governments. If created, the new assemblies will use full
representation. June 17, 2003.
The Guardian: ���Regional government around the world .���
English author compares the local governments of Canada, Austria,
Belgium, Finland, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, the Netherlands,
Poland, and Portugal. June 16, 2003.
The Guardian : ���Now the House of Lords will remain a laughing stock:
any chance of reform has gone thanks to Blair���s moment of
madness .��� Editorial bemoaning the narrow failure of a
measure in the British House of Commons, which would have changed
the House of Lords into a directly elected body. The author
advocates full representation. February 5, 2003.
The Guardian : ���PR on the backburner: It���s a big idea whose time has
not yet come .��� The author sympathizes with British
Liberal Democrat leader���s decision to focus on other policy agendas
besides full representation. January 28, 2003.
The Guardian: ���Voting change would be fitting legacy, say
campaigners.��� The director of Make
Votes Count, a British full representation group, laments
the death of full representation advocate Lord Jenkins, and
discusses the possibilities for full representation in Britain in
2003. January 6, 2003.
UK (Northern
Ireland) Try these links
for background information on Northern Irish politics and elections:
Electionworld.org: Northern
Ireland, Wikipedia.org: Northern Ireland, and
Ace Project.
New Zealand Herald: "Hard-liners victorious in Northern
Ireland." Describes the results of the Northern Ireland
Assembly elections. November 29, 2003. See also Northern
Ireland Elections web page.
BBC News: "NI - Making
sense of the maths." Explanation of the electoral system
in Northern Ireland. November 27, 2003.
Guardian Unlimited: "Q&A: the Northern Ireland
elections." Nick McDermott explains the unique voting
system which will be used in the Stormont assembly and executive
elections. November 21, 2003.
UK (Scotland) Try this link for background information on Scottish politics
and elections: Wikipedia.org: Scotland, Psephos: Scotland
The Scotsman: "How we Scots vote should be up to us."
Margo MacDonald argues that the Scottish parliament (rather than
Westminster) should decide on what the voting system should be. The
piece also gives an overview of where the different parties stand on
the issue of electoral reform. February 11, 2004.
The Herald: "Darling speeds up
electoral reform plan." A commission is to be established
to consider constituency boundaries for Scottish parliament and the
potential impact of four different electoral models on civic life in
Scotland. February 9, 2004.
The Scotsman: "Boundary changes 'will
stifle Scottish democracy'." The Labour and Tory parties
are being criticized for supporting proposals to decrease the number
of members of parliament elected using the list system. Opponents
claim that in backing this plan, they are attempting to take power
away from the smaller parties. February 4, 2004.
The Scotsman on Sunday: "McConnell urged to
change rules for PR voting." Opposition parties are
urging First Minister Jack McConnell to make the planned full
representation system fairer by allowing some constituencies to have
five representatives and others to have just two. February 1,
2004.
The Scotsman: "Executive Advised to Make PR Vote Plans
Fairer." Political parties are negotiating a full
representation bill in Parliament. The STV working group has
suggested that wards be represented by up to five ministers, which
is supported by the Liberal Democrats but opposed by larger parties
such as Labour, which favors three to four ministers per ward.
January 28, 2004.
The Scotsman: "Electoral System
Change 'Could Stop Extremist Parties'." Ken Ritchie of
the Electoral Reform Society comments on the likely effects of full
representation on the power of certain political parties in
Scotland. January 20, 2004. See more details on the ERS website.
The Herald: "Labour MPs in talks on Holyrood poll
plans." In a special meeting being held to discuss the
voting system for parliament, former Scotland Office minister George
Foulkes will advocate full representation in all constituencies.
January 13, 2004
The Herald: "Foulkes wants bigger
role for PR at Holyrood." Former deputy secretary of
state George Foulkes proposes reforming the system for electing MSPs
by switching entirely to full representation. January 7, 2004.
Sunday Herald: ���McConnell: 50% of councilors must be
women.��� In addition to changing to choice voting for
local council elections in Scotland, First Minister Jack McConnell
and other Scottish Labor Party leaders intend to reserve nearly half
of the council seats for women. Most local councilors in the
Scottish Labour party are male. However, a 28-22 majority of the
Members of the Scottish Parliament from the Scottish Labour party
are female. This is because the Scottish Parliament already has a
rule about dividing nominations for equally winnable seats between
men and women. June 1, 2003.
The Herald : ���Marwick on attack after PR bill defeated .���
In Scotland, both the Conservative Party and the Labor party have
prepared bills for using choice voting in Scottish local elections.
However, the Conservative bill was ready for vote in February, but
the Labor bill will not be ready until after the elections in May.
Although the Liberal Democrats are core supporters of choice voting,
they voted against the February bill, drawing heavy criticism from
the National party. February 7, 2003.
BBC News : ���Council vote changes outlined: The bill would change
how councillors are elected .��� The Scottish Executive has
published a draft bill that would change the method of electing
local government from plurality to choice voting. However, the
Scottish National Party, who are in favor of using STV, are critical
of the fact that the draft bill is being published too late to be
considered before the next elections. February 4, 2003.
A draft copy of the Local Governance
(Scotland) Bill is available in PDF . If passed, the bill will
establish choice voting for Scottish local elections, effective in
time for the next round of elections.
UK (Wales)
Try these links for background on Welsh
politics: National Assembly for Wales website , Wikipedia.org: Wales, Psephos: Wales
IC North Wales: "Let Assembly make laws,
says minister." Environment Minister Carwyn Jones pushes
for greater law-making powers for the Welsh Assembly. He also calls
for reforms, including increasing the number of representatives and
doing away with the current full representation model. January 26,
2004.
The Western Mail: ���Assembly rejects poll changes .��� Although
an independent commission created by a past government recommended
choice voting for Welsh council elections, the current government
has rejected the recommendation. July 17, 2003.
IC Wales : ���Hain opposed to new Assembly powers .���
Peter Hain speaks against devolving more power to the Welsh
Assembly. Hain is also opposed to full representation, which is used
in Assembly elections. July 7, 2003.
The Guardian: ���Scargill to stand in Welsh elections.���
Article discusses the candidacy of Arthur Scargill for the Welsh
assembly, which is elected by a form of mixed member proportional
representation (or ���additional member system,��� as it is known in the
UK). Arthur Scargill is running for the Socialist Labour party.
February 12, 2003.
The Western Mail : ���Ron Davies warns Labour of Plaid Victory .���
Former Welsh Secretary states that the Labour party needs to present
an inspiring platform in order to retain control of the Welsh
Assembly. February 10, 2003.
US (Puerto Rico)
Try these
links for background information on Puerto Rican politics and
elections: Elections in Puerto Rico, Comisi��n Estatal
de Elecciones de Puerto Rico, Electionworld.org: Puerto Rico, Wikipedia: Puerto Rico
Elections to Puerto Rico's Legislative
Assembly: A brief description of the voting systems used
to elect the two houses of Puerto Rico's Legislative Assembly.
Full Representation and Proportionality in Puerto
Rico: Text and table analyzing the results of the
November 2000 Legislative Assembly election in terms of votes and
seats won by each party. Compares the proportionality of the single
non-transferable vote (SNTV) benches in the assembly to the single
member district plurality benches, and finds a dramatically higher
disproportionality in the plurality benches.
|